- On Environmental, Social, And Governance
- Increased Risk Highlights Need for ESG Analysis in Municipal Bond Market
- ESG factors are having an increasing impact on municipal bonds.
- 2021-06-25 12:09
- Key Insights
- The generally high‑quality, low‑volatility profile of municipal bonds, and the tax‑advantaged income generated, underscores the appeal of this asset class.
- Increasingly, environmental, social, and governance (ESG) factors are playing a key role in assessing the risk environment for the municipal bond market.
- The integration of ESG factors, alongside traditional fundamental credit analysis, is an increasingly crucial part of municipal bond investment decisions.
Understanding the impacts of climate change and growing economic inequality are key to assessing the risk landscape for municipal bonds.
As the United States continues to experience the impacts of climate change—wildfires, extreme storms, rising sea levels, hotter heat waves, longer droughts—we expect to see knock‑on implications for the municipal bond market. It seems reasonable to suggest that, over time, state, city, and local governments will need to issue more bonds to finance the infrastructure required to build a more climate resilient country.
For example, the combination of population growth and changing precipitation patterns are threatening the sustainability of water supplies from the Colorado River, one of the most important water resources in the semiarid Western United States. Prolonged water shortages on the Colorado River will likely have a cascading effect on a wide range of factors, including agriculture, forestry, energy, drinking water, and tourism—these in turn will impact the fortunes of municipal bond issuers in the region in our view.
Another issue that is changing the risk landscape for municipal bonds is the rise of social inequality, which has sadly been amplified by the coronavirus pandemic. Every three years, the Federal Reserve releases its Survey of Consumer Finances. The latest report shows how rising income gains and home prices have fueled an improvement in overall personal finances—but it also highlights how that growth is concentrated in the top 10% (Figure 1).
Understanding how issues like climate change and inequality will affect municipal bond issuers is an increasingly more important part of a credit analyst’s job. These are two issues that fall under the umbrella of environmental, social, and governance (ESG) analysis. At T. Rowe Price, we have embedded ESG analysis across our investment research platform. This includes developing a specific framework for municipal bond analysis.
Improvement in Overall Wealth has Been Concentrated in the Top 10%
(Fig. 1) The coronavirus has also amplified social inequality
As of December 31, 2019.
All figures are in U.S. dollars. Stock holdings include indirect ownership, including through 401(k) accounts.
Source: U.S. Federal Reserve.
The Appeal of Municipal Bonds
The U.S. municipal bond market is composed of sub‑sovereign debt issued by cities, states, counties, or other local governments. Additionally, not‑for‑profit entities, such as hospitals and higher education institutions, also issue in the municipal bond market. The bonds are broadly divided into two categories: (i) general obligation bonds backed by tax inflows and (ii) revenue bonds backed by revenues from a specific project, such as toll roads. In addition to the generally high‑quality and low‑volatility profile of the municipal bond market, the tax‑advantaged nature of the income generated further enhances the appeal of municipal bonds. At a minimum, income is exempt from federal tax, and depending on where the bonds are issued, may also be free of state and local taxes. (Note: federal alternative minimum tax (AMT) may apply for some investors.) With expectations of a higher tax environment in the U.S., the tax exemption is particularly attractive, especially for U.S.‑based investors on a higher marginal tax rate.
"...the municipal market is inherently ESG‑focused, providing essential funding for key projects around the country."
— Hugh McGuirk Head of Municipal Bond Team
At the same time, the municipal market is inherently ESG‑focused, providing essential funding for key projects around the country. The proceeds from state and local government debt issuance often contribute to positive social and environmental outcomes, funding either new or upgraded physical infrastructure (water treatment plants, transportation links, hospitals, etc.) or improvements in the social infrastructure, such as in education, health care, and renewable energy.
Sustainability Risk Has Increased
The coronavirus pandemic created considerable headwinds for the municipal market, and while many issuers, with the assistance of federal aid, fared better than expected, it will take some time before the full impact of the crisis becomes clear. State governments’ frontline health care spending, for example, were at greatly elevated levels, while a shift in housing preferences, out of cities, is also evident. As such, the integration of ESG factor analysis, alongside traditional fundamental credit analysis, serves as a crucial input in determining the overall credit quality of municipal bonds.
"...the integration of ESG factor analysis, alongside traditional fundamental credit analysis, serves as a crucial input in determining the overall credit quality of municipal bonds."
— Maria Elena Drew Director of Research, Responsible Investing
We believe that governance factors, such as poor budgetary practices or corruption, will affect an issuer’s ability to raise revenues from taxes or other types of income. Similarly, those issuers that think beyond immediate budgetary needs and make investments intended to strengthen the social fabric of their communities are likely to be advantaged, as inclusive communities tend to be more settled and harmonious and, thus, pose potentially lower risk for issuers. Meanwhile, environmental criteria, such as the carbon footprint of a state’s energy production or the risk of natural hazards, will likely be key influences on creditworthiness. Where the latter is concerned, the California wildfires or the hurricanes that periodically batter the East Coast highlight the kind of natural event risk that can cause extreme damage to property and severely disrupt human and economic activity.
Regulation and Disclosure Standards
It is also important to note that municipal bonds are not subject to the same regulation and disclosure requirements as corporate bonds, for example. This further highlights the need for a bespoke, hands‑on approach to ESG analysis within the municipal bond market in order to fully understand the potential risks associated with each issuer. This deep understanding is also key in navigating a path of engagement and encouraging good governance.
Our ESG Investing Approach
ESG analysis is one of the many building blocks that make up T. Rowe Price’s investment research platform. We have invested heavily in people and systems to develop a comprehensive, systematic, and proactive process for evaluating ESG factors that could impact our investments.
Responsible Investing Indicator Model (RIIM) Framework for Municipal Bonds
(Fig. 2) The unique nature of municipal bonds requires a bespoke approach to ESG analysis
For illustrative purposes only.
*Green (circle) indicates no/few flags, orange (square) indicates medium flags, red (triangle) indicates high flags.
Integrating ESG Factors to Enhance Investment Decisions
ESG analysis is integrated into our fundamental investment process, which means ESG factors are considered in tandem with traditional criteria, such as financial, valuation, macroeconomic, and other factors as part of investment decision‑making (as appropriate to the strategy). Our philosophy is that ESG factors are a component of the investment decision: They are not the sole driver of an investment decision, nor are they considered separately from more traditional analysis.
While governance and social risk are a big part of the municipal bond market and our analysts have long included analysis of these factors as part of their research, more recently we have added better capabilities to evaluate environmental risk. Additionally, we have formalized our ESG analysis with the development of a framework designed specifically for municipal bonds called the Responsible Investing Indicator Model (RIIM). Unlike other asset classes, quantitative ESG data sets are less developed for municipal bond issuers—so we have taken a differentiated approach to ESG analysis for this asset class. Our approach leverages the external research providers as well as the investment research conducted by our credit analysts and portfolio managers.
Importantly, our analysis focuses on the ESG factors deemed to have a material impact on the performance of investments in our clients’ portfolios. The following graphic describes the two‑stage integration process.
For credits with orange or red assessments, analysts must address the underlying reasons in their formal review of the credit and should include them in the conclusion and recommendation section of their report. Any red assessments are to be immediately brought to the attention of the portfolio manager(s).
The example below is a high‑level illustration of the ESG factors considered in our evaluation process and the scoring table that is included in each credit’s formal review.
One of the benefits of applying a formalized ESG framework to our analysis is that it provides a way to measure these environmental, social, and governance factors. This makes it easier to compare issuers on what are oftentimes quite qualitative factors.
Another benefit to our RIIM municipal bond framework is that it has strengthened our environmental analysis, providing a deeper and more rounded perspective on the specific environmental risks of individual municipal bonds. Our analysis includes geospatial research tools provided by a third party that help identify if an issuer might be exposed to coastal flooding, drought, or other environmental risks. Once identified, our credit analysts can drill deeper to determine the materiality of that risk, considering things like the concentration of economic activity and the potential business disruption, as well as any mitigation policies or strategies in place should such a climate event occur.
ESG Integration in Action—Illustrative Example
(Fig. 3) State of California
As of September 15, 2020.
This material is provided as a historical case study and is for informational purposes only. This material is not intended to be investment advice or a recommendation to take any particular investment action. The views contained herein are as of the date noted above, and do not necessarily reflect those of the firm, and may have changed since that time.
Source: T. Rowe Price.
For municipal bond investors, ESG risks incorporate the long‑term sustainability of a project and the possibility of lower costs, reduced waste, and more efficiency over time, which will likely contribute to underlying credit strength. Research suggests that the implementation of sustainable practices can create efficiencies to potentially improve investor value and mitigate risk over time. Accordingly, we see the integration of ESG factors, alongside traditional fundamental credit analysis, as a crucial part of the investment decision‑making process. However, the unique and complex nature of the municipal bond market requires a bespoke approach to ESG analysis. Ultimately, we believe that integrating ESG analysis provides a more comprehensive view of issuer creditworthiness and a better understanding of broader risk factors over time.
This material is provided for general and educational purposes only, and is not intended to provide legal, tax or investment advice.
The views contained herein are those of the authors as of June 2021 and are subject to change without notice; these views may differ from those of other T. Rowe Price associates.
This information is not intended to reflect a current or past recommendation concerning investments, investment strategies, or account types, advice of any kind, or a solicitation of an offer to buy or sell any securities or investment services. The opinions and commentary provided do not take into account the investment objectives or financial situation of any particular investor or class of investor. Please consider your own circumstances before making an investment decision. Please consult your independent legal counsel and/or tax professional regarding any legal or tax issues raised in this material.
Information contained herein is based upon sources we consider to be reliable; we do not, however, guarantee its accuracy.
Past performance is not a reliable indicator of future performance. All investments are subject to market risk, including the possible loss of principal. Fixed‑income securities are subject to credit risk, liquidity risk, call risk, and interest‑rate risk. As interest rates rise, bond prices generally fall. ESG investments may not succeed in generating a positive environmental and/or social impact. There is no assurance that any investment objective will be achieved. All charts and tables are shown for illustrative purposes only.
T. Rowe Price Investment Services, Inc.
© 2021 T. Rowe Price. All Rights Reserved. T. ROWE PRICE, INVEST WITH CONFIDENCE, and the Bighorn Sheep design are, collectively and/or apart, trademarks of T. Rowe Price Group, Inc.