Global Economics

Is There Going to Be a Eurozone Recession in 2020?

The traditional leading indicators are saying different things.
February 2020
Tomasz Wieladek, T. Rowe Price International Economist

Key Insights
  • Two leading eurozone recession indicators—the German bund yield curve and M1 money growth—are currently giving very different signals.
  • Our analysis suggests that neither may be particularly reliable this time because central bank quantitative easing (QE) has weakened the predictive power of both.
  • Consumer and business surveys continue to be reliable predictors of recession in the age of QE—and these suggest the risk of a recession in 2020 is low.


The inversion1 of the German bund yield curve in the third quarter of last year raised concerns that the eurozone may be heading for a recession (like a U.S. Treasury yield curve inversion, an inverted bund yield curve is regarded as a harbinger of recession). However, eurozone M1 (currency supply in circulation) growth, which is also seen as a reliable indicator of recession, is currently signaling a return to expansion. Which of these two measures should we trust?

German bund yield curve inversions have preceded recessions in Europe since before the euro was formally adopted in 1999 (see Figure 1). There are three probable reasons for this: First, past recessions in Germany have tended to spill over into other economies in mainland Europe; second, German yield curve inversions have reflected macroeconomic shocks in common with all large economies in Europe; and third, prior to the euro, the German deutsche mark was the anchor currency of the European Monetary System of exchange rates, which meant that German yield curve inversions following monetary tightening always likely led to a slowdown/recession in other countries as well.

Following the adoption of the euro in 1999, inversion in the bund market continued to be a reliable predictor of recessions in the eurozone. This is likely because Germany has one of the highest degrees of financial development in the eurozone and its lack of sovereign risk—unlike, say, Spain and Italy—means that bund yields are more reflective of European Central Bank (ECB) policy rate expectations than term premia.2 However, during this period, the yield curve inversion also appears to have once sent a false signal: In the first quarter of 2001, the yield curve inverted but no eurozone‑wide recession followed. There was a recession in Germany and then France, but Italy, Spain, and other European countries remained recession‑free as they were experiencing very rapid credit growth as a direct result of the creation of the euro. It is, however, unlikely that these mitigating conditions will be repeated, and inversions in the German yield curve have once again reliably indicated future eurozone recessions.

Real M1 growth has also been a very reliable predictor of eurozone recessions. A large fall in real M1 growth has preceded every eurozone recession, while rebounds typically hail a recovery. As with the inverted yield curve, there is no consensus among economists about the precise mechanism underlying the predictive power of real M1 growth. However, it is broadly accepted that large swings in real narrow money (M1) aggregates affect asset prices, leading to large wealth effects, which, in turn, influence aggregate demand and help to predict turning points in the cycle.

"German bund yield curve inversions have preceded recessions in Europe since before the euro was adopted."

Until recently, real M1 growth and the bund yield curve typically provided the same signal ahead of a recession. However, the most recent real M1 growth rates have been strong by historical standards. This means that, for the first time, the yield curve has inverted (signaling eurozone recession) at the same time that M1 money supply has continued to grow robustly (signaling a return to expansion). Determining which of these signals is correct is a key question for eurozone bond investors in 2020.

Are Macrofinancial Indicators Reliable in the Age of QE?

In truth, however, it is possible that neither the yield curve nor M1 growth are particularly reliable indicators of the likelihood of a recession on this occasion because central bank QE has weakened the predictive power of both. The yield curve consists of a term premium and an interest rate expectation component. When bond markets are convinced that a period of long monetary easing lies ahead, the interest rate expectation component will push the long‑term rate below the short‑term rate, leading to a yield curve inversion ahead of recession. However, by purchasing government debt, central banks have relied on compressing the spread between the long‑term and short‑term government bond yields. This explicit intervention in the bond market means that it probably takes less negative news to invert the curve than in the past, limiting the efficacy of a yield curve inversion as a predictor of recession.

Similarly, a large component of M1 is the central bank’s balance sheet. Any large central bank balance sheet expansion, whether due to QE or long‑term refinancing operation, can, therefore, distort the recession signal sent by M1, especially if it is spread over many months as in the case of the ECB’s QE.

"...for the first time, the yield curve has inverted at the same time that M1 money supply has continued to grow robustly."

Our internal research backs up these concerns. We collected data on the share of government debt on central bank balance sheets for the G7 economies from 1986–2011, then analyzed the strengths of the poly‑serial correlation between these indicators and recessions two quarters ahead. The results from this exercise, illustrated in Figure 2, show that the yield curve spread and real M1 growth predict recession well when the share of government debt on the central bank balance sheet is less than 0.4% (they are negatively correlated, so a positive yield curve spread or strong real M1 growth implies a low recession risk). However, if the share of government debt on central bank balance sheets is greater than 6%, then these variables have the wrong sign (positive correlation)—and have therefore lost their predictive power.

Which Variables Remain Reliable Indicators of Recession?

If yield curve inversion and real M1 growth are less reliable indicators of a recession in the age of QE, what other signals can investors turn to?

Our analysis suggests that consumer confidence and business surveys continue to be correlated with recession risks even when the central bank owns more than 6% of government debt. We include these variables into a standard predictive model of recession based on the bund yield curve (see Figure 3). These additional variables clearly improve the predictive power of the model for past recessions, raising the probability of recessions before they actually occur and lowering false signals. For 2020, this model indicates that the probability of recession is just above zero—much lower than the 27% implied by the yield curve model alone.

"...consumer confidence and business surveys continue to be correlated with recession risks even when the central bank owns more than 6% of government debt."

Among the surveys, the most reliable statistical predictor of recession two quarters ahead is consumer confidence. While the age of QE persists, investors may find it useful to consider consumer confidence surveys in addition to the bund yield curve and real M1 growth when assessing eurozone recession risks. At present, consumer confidence surveys are predicting there will not be a eurozone recession this year.

What we’re watching next

To assess recession risks in times of QE, we are now watching both business and consumer surveys. While business surveys such as PMIs have only begun to improve, consumer confidence surveys remain at strong levels. We will continue watching these surveys to assess imminent recession risks.

1 When long-term yields are lower than short-term yields.

2 The amount that the yield on a long-term bond exceeds that of a short-term bond.

Important Information

This material is provided for informational purposes only and is not intended to be investment advice or a recommendation to take any particular investment action.

The views contained herein are those of the authors as of February 2020 and are subject to change without notice; these views may differ from those of other T. Rowe Price associates.

This information is not intended to reflect a current or past recommendation, investment advice of any kind, or a solicitation of an offer to buy or sell any securities or investment services. The opinions and commentary provided do not take into account the investment objectives or financial situation of any particular investor or class of investor. Investors will need to consider their own circumstances before making an investment decision.

Information contained herein is based upon sources we consider to be reliable; we do not, however, guarantee its accuracy.

Past performance is not a reliable indicator of future performance. All investments are subject to market risk, including the possible loss of principal. All charts and tables are shown for illustrative purposes only.

T. Rowe Price Investment Services, Inc.

© 2020 T. Rowe Price. All rights reserved. T. ROWE PRICE, INVEST WITH CONFIDENCE, and the bighorn sheep design are, collectively and/or apart, trademarks or registered trademarks of T. Rowe Price Group, Inc.

Dismiss
Tap to dismiss

Manage Subscriptions

Unsubscribe All
OK

Manage your watched Funds and Insights subscriptions from the mobile menu.

Mobile Watchlist Menu

Manage your watched Funds and Insights subscriptions here.

OK

Change Details

Congratulations! You are now registered.

Begin watching and receiving email updates for:

Ok

Sign in to manage your subscriptions and watch list.

Register

Download

Latest Date Range
Download Cancel

This content is restricted for Institutional Investors use only. We were not able to validate your status as an Institutional Investor with the information you provided at registration.

Please contact the T. Rowe Price Team with questions or to revise your status.

1-800-564-6958

You will need to accept the Terms & Conditions again.

Ok

You have updated your email address.

An activation email has been sent to your new email address from T. Rowe Price.

Please click on the activation link in order to receive email updates.

Ok

You have an existing account

Click OK to view your subscriptions and watch list.

OK

Confirm Cancel