US Economy: What Does a Flattening Yield Curve Mean?
- The Treasury yield curve tends to flatten as economic expansions age, and it has become inverted before each of the last nine recessions, dating back to 1955.
- However, in the last five such instances, the S&P 500 has delivered positive returns three times over the 12 months following curve flattening.
- As of the end of September of this year, the yield was not yet flat, but it could be by next March if the Fed maintains its tightening pace and the 10-year Treasury rate continues above the 3.0% level.
The U.S. Treasury yield curve—the spread between long- and short-term rates—has flattened sharply this year, raising questions and concerns about the implications of a flat or inverted yield curve for the economy and investing environment (see Figure 1).
Figure 1: U.S. Treasury Yield Spread Narrowed
Difference Between 2- and 10-Year Yields
Sources: Federal Reserve, National Bureau for Economic Research, Haver Analytics, and data analysis by T. Rowe Price.
Indeed, while the yield curve is usually positively sloped, with long-term rates higher than short-term rates, it tends to flatten as economic expansions age. And it has become inverted—with short rates higher than long rates—before each of the last nine recessions, dating to 1955.
In these cases, the spread between 10-year and three-year Treasury notes flattened, reaching a yield spread of zero, on average 16 months before the onset of each of these nine recessions, as determined by the National Bureau for Economic Research. The lead times ranged from nine months to 28 months.
The record for the more commonly cited 10-year to two-year yield spread—from 1976, when the Treasury began issuing two-year notes—is broadly similar.
That spread has flattened before each of the last five recessions, on average 16 months before the recession begins, with a range of 10 to 22 months. It stood at 0.24% on September 30 of this year, down from a 2018 high of 0.78% on February 12.
There are causal linkages connecting yield curve changes and the business cycle because these late-cycle episodes of curve flattening and inversion are driven by monetary policy.
When the Fed raises interest rates to cap inflation or prevent other manifestations of an overheating economy, interest rates generally have tended to rise at all maturities. Short-term rates have tended to rise in these instances more than long-term rates, as the former are more closely tied to the overnight fed funds rate, which is the Fed’s policy instrument.
Higher interest rates reduce the demand for credit, and a flatter yield curve reduces the profit margin of banks and other borrow-short, lend-long financial intermediaries—thereby restricting the supply of credit.
There also are less direct channels through which Fed rate hikes affect the financial conditions that drive economic decision-making.
For example, rising interest rates can be a headwind for stock prices by reducing the discounted value of expected corporate earnings, and they can boost the foreign exchange value of the dollar, undermining the competitiveness of U.S. exports and reducing the dollar value of multinationals’ foreign earnings.
In part because of the varying time span between complete curve flattening and the onset of recession, there is significant variation in investment returns once the yield curve reaches zero spread.
In the five most recent episodes (for which stock and bond market total return data are available), the Standard & Poor’s 500 Index of large-cap U.S. stocks delivered a positive total return three times over the 12 months following curve flattening. Negative total returns were posted in the two cycles that had the shortest time span between curve flattening and recession (see Figure 2).
Figure 2: Returns After Yield Spread Hits Zero and Recessions Followed
U.S. Stocks and Bonds, 12 Months Later
Past performance is not a reliable indicator of future performance.
Indices used are the S&P 500 Index and the Bloomberg Barclays U.S. Aggregate Bond Index.
Sources: Bloomberg Index Services Ltd., Federal Reserve, Standard & Poor’s, Haver Analytics, and data analysis by T. Rowe Price.
Bloomberg Index Services Ltd. Copyright © 2018. Bloomberg Index Services Ltd. Used with permission.
The yield curve is not flat yet as of the end of September of this year, but it could be by next March if the Fed maintains its 0.25% per quarter pace of rate hikes and the 10-year Treasury rate continues above the 3.0% level.
Starting the historical average 16-month clock from the spring of 2019 would raise the specter of a downturn beginning in 2020. But a recession would not necessarily be precipitated by the flat yield curve per se because the underlying stance of monetary policy likely would not be particularly restrictive.
Indeed, if the curve flattens next March as the Fed lifts its fed funds rate target range to 2.5% to 2.75%, the real fed funds rate would still only be 0.5% to 0.75%—more than a full percentage point below the economy’s current estimated growth potential.
This would represent a relatively accommodative underlying policy stance. In previous interest rate cycles, the real fed funds rate has been roughly equal to the potential economic growth rate when the yield curve reached zero spread.
In other words, we may expect the potential recession signal of a flat yield curve to be confirmed by further Fed rate hikes that raise real interest rates to the economy’s current estimated growth potential of roughly 2.0%.
But, in fact, the curve flattening since February of this year has been driven entirely by higher two-year rates, reflecting that sort of rise in the expected fed funds rate two years later. More than nine years from the mid-2009 recession trough, the current nearly flat yield curve is a sign that the growth cycle is in its later stages, but history counsels against trying to pinpoint the next recession. Similarly, the record of asset market performance in the year following curve flattening argues against hunkering down in anticipation of an imminent recession.
Additionally, it’s important to keep in mind that while a flat yield curve will be an important milestone in this long-running economic expansion, there are other indicators to watch for signs of emerging economic fragility.
These include not only the fed funds rate reaching the economy’s potential economic growth rate, but also a softening labor market—as a significant downshift in the pace of monthly job growth and a sustained upturn in weekly jobless claims would indicate an inflection point in the economy’s growth trajectory.
This material is being furnished for general informational purposes only. The material does not constitute or undertake to give advice of any nature, including fiduciary investment advice, and prospective investors are recommended to seek independent legal, financial and tax advice before making any investment decision. T. Rowe Price group of companies including T. Rowe Price Associates, Inc. and/or its affiliates receive revenue from T. Rowe Price investment products and services. Past performance is not a reliable indicator of future performance. The value of an investment and any income from it can go down as well as up. Investors may get back less than the amount invested.
The material does not constitute a distribution, an offer, an invitation, a personal or general recommendation or solicitation to sell or buy any securities in any jurisdiction or to conduct any particular investment activity. The material has not been reviewed by any regulatory authority in any jurisdiction.
Information and opinions presented have been obtained or derived from sources believed to be reliable and current; however, we cannot guarantee the sources' accuracy or completeness. There is no guarantee that any forecasts made will come to pass. The views contained herein are as of the date noted on the material and are subject to change without notice; these views may differ from those of other T. Rowe Price group companies and/or associates. Under no circumstances should the material, in whole or in part, be copied or redistributed without consent from T. Rowe Price.
The material is not intended for use by persons in jurisdictions which prohibit or restrict the distribution of the material and in certain countries the material is provided upon specific request.
It is not intended for distribution to retail investors in any jurisdiction.